Ceistean

[bodach]

Re Beag air bheag, Aonad 10
A bheil 'fidhle' agus 'fidheall' ionann?

Ann an Transcript 2,
Q: An toigh leat ... ?
A: Is toil. Is toigh leam ...
Carson toigh ... toil ... toigh ?

Mar an ceudna,
Q: Am bi thu ...?
A: Bithidh. Bídh mi ...
Tri cruthan?

Re Little by little, Unit 10
Are 'fidhle' and 'fidheall' identical in meaning?

In Transcript 2,
Q: Do you like ..?
A: Yes. I like ...
Why the two forms?

Similarly bi, bith, bithidh -- 3 forms?

Any light shed on these would be appreciated.

[GunChleoc]

Re Beag air bheag, Aonad 10
A bheil 'fidhle' agus 'fidheall' ionann?

fìdheall is in common case and fìdhle in genitive case. The only difference is their position in the sentence structure.

Ann an Transcript 2,
Q: An toigh leat ... ?
A: Is toil. Is toigh leam ...
Carson toigh ... toil ... toigh ?

This is a spelling variation. toigh is the older and more correct form, toil is what GOC tells us to use (and results in learner pronunciation errors with the vowel - it took me 10 years to notice, and I'm still trying to get rid of that one...). Since toigh is usually followed by leam/leat/le etc, some people just started adding the l to the end of toigh: toigh l' => toil.

Mar an ceudna,
Q: Am bi thu ...?
A: Bithidh. Bídh mi ...
Tri cruthan?

bi: dependent form (after question words, cha etc.)
bithidh, bidh: both are the indepentent form (nothing in front of it). bithidh is emphasized and 2 syllables long. bidh is not emphasized and 1 syllable long.

[bodach]

Tha mi buidheach airson do cuideachadh -- a-rithist!!

[GunChleoc]

Tha thu làn di-beathte