Níall Beag wrote:Have I not always said that FtMnG was full of people who don't speak Gaelic? *
I see this differently.
It's quite possible that the teacher in question does NOT 'speak' Gaelic badly, but is in fact a native-speaker who can deal with spoken Gaelic perfectly well, just hadn't had much if any Gaelic-language schooling him/herself, so makes spelling/punctuation mistakes when writing. This is the case with many of the perfectly fluent native-speakers I know.)
If the focus is on letting children in the first couple of years get exposure to natural spoken Gaelic and the chance to use it naturally, then a native-speaker is probably better than a learner with schoolbook grammar, punctuation etc.
The homework is presumably an aide-memoire for the children, reflecting things practised orally in class, not the Bible when it comes to (later more thorough) reading and writing.
Ideally you would have both elements, the native-speaker with both Gaelic language training and teacher-training, and we should strive towards that, but we are not at that stage yet, and personally I think if we wait till we are, it will be too late. Aiseag air falbh.